Chapter Five

Home Contents Introduction Chapter One Chapter Two Chapter Three Chapter Four Chapter Five Chapter Six Links Outlines, PP, Studies Bible Study Aids Crain Home Web

Chapter Five: Structure and Form

Content without structure can overwhelm us. That's why the first sections have addressed types of literature, historical chronology, civilizations and themes; another approach that is often helpful for students is to begin with an understanding of how the anthology itself is structured. What I will do next is provide several structures to help students grasp what the anthology as a whole is.

 

Let me begin with the ordering provided by the Oxford Companion to the Bible:

Names and Order of the Books of the Old and New Testaments with the Apocryphal/Deuterocanonical Books (Dates established from Oxford Annotation to NRSV) :

The Hebrew Scriptures
Genesis --950 BC E. to Exile from sources J, E, D, P
Exodus-- 950 BC E. to Exile from sources J, E, D, P
Leviticus--950 BC E. to Exile from sources J, E, D, P
Numbers --950 BC E. to Exile from sources J, E, D, P
Deuteronomy--950 BC E. to Exile from sources J, E, D, P


[A word about JEPD sources: the (J)Judah source is dated to 950 BCE, the result of a written epic organized by a traditionist of that time; the later E is the work of another traditionist from Ephraim written some time around 900-750 BCE This is followed by the Deuteronomic writings of the seventh century BC E. The Priestly (P) source is given shape at about the time of the Exile.]


Joshua--pervaded by style and philosophy of Deuteronomy
Judges --writer reveals Deuteronomic concerns for loyalty to God as prerequisite for success, appearing in classic form in Deuteronomy 28
Ruth --post exile based on older tale
1 Samuel (1 Kingdoms in Greek) --final editing, post-exile; early (time of Solomon) and late source; early source is single writer deserving the title "father of history" usually given to Herodotus, five hundred years later
2 Samuel (2 Kingdoms in Greek) --same as 1 Samuel
1 Kings (3 Kingdoms in Greek) --based on various sources including annals and temple archives, written by two Deuteronomic author-editors, just before or after King Josiah's death in 609 BC E and during the Babylonian exile for 2 Kings
2 Kings (4 Kingdoms in Greek)
1 Chronicles (1 Paralipomenon in Greek) -400-250 BCE
2 Chronicles (2 Paralipomenon in Greek) -400-250 BCE
Ezra (= 2 Esdras in Greek) -part of Chronicler's work, 400-250 B.C.E
Nehemiah (= 2 Esdras in Greek) -part of Chronicler's work, 400-250 B.C.E
Esther --some think it was written during Maccabean times but is probably earlier, written as propaganda for the observance in Palestine to celebrate Purim
Job --folktale circulating early (1000-800 B.C.E), written down in the time of David or Solomon
Psalms --ancient hymnal compiled from older collection of lyrics, half ascribed to David
Proverbs --includes older material from long tradition, compiled during post-exile period for moral and religious instruction
Ecclesiastes --third century B. C. E., although traditionally assigned to Solomon; contains echoes of Greek philosophy
Song of Solomon --based on ancient materials; given form in three hundred B. C. E.
Isaiah --1-39 assigned to Isaiah's time, 742-687 B.C.E; 40-66, immediately before the fall of Babylon; 56-69, 63-66, and 60-62, 530-510 BCE
Jeremiah --edited after 560 BC E.
Lamentations --laments desolation of Jerusalem, after 587 BCE
Ezekiel --1-24 oracles of warning to be dated before the fall of Jerusalem; 25-32 oracles of hope after the fall of Jerusalem; middle 25-32 oracles against nations to middle period of Ezekiel's life, 587-585 BCE
Daniel --written by a Jew during the time of Antiochus Epiphanies 167-164 BCE
Hosea --twelve minor prophets constituted a unit by second century BCE; Hosea's ministry to northern kingdom follows closely that of Amos; before the fall of 721 BCE
Joel --400-350 BCE; no mention of Assyrians or Babylonians; heavy borrowing from earlier prophets
Amos --760-750 BCE; called to task of providing harsh words to a prospering northern kingdom under Jeroboam II
Obadiah--soon after Jerusalem fell to the Babylonians; indicts Edomites
Jonah --didactic narrative drawing on legend; tells story of prophet under Jeroboam II (786-746 BCE) who resists difficult task of crying against Nineveh, capital for the Assyrian empire
Micah --Micah is contemporary with Isaiah; prosperity of northern kingdom ends with death of Jeroboam II; chapter 7's picture of restored Jerusalem is post-exilic
Nahum--ode foretells fall of Nineveh; Nineveh was destroyed in 612 BCE
Habakkuk --work of Hebrew prophet during height of Babylonian power
Zephaniah --days of Josiah, before 621 B.C.E
Haggai --five addresses in 520 BCE exhorting Zerubbabel to reconstruct the temple
Zechariah--contains pre-exile bits but seems to be written during Greek period
Malachi --500-450 BCE

The Apocryphal/Deuterocanonical Books


The Apocryphal/Deuterocanonical Books are listed here in four groupings, as follows:
(a) Books and Additions to Esther and Daniel that are in the Roman Catholic, Greek, and Slavonic Bibles.
Tobit
Judith
The Additions to the Book of Esther (with a translation of the entire Greek text of Esther)
Wisdom of Solomon
Ecclesiasticus, or the Wisdom of Jesus Son of Sirach
Baruch
The Letter of Jeremiah (=Baruch ch. 6)
The Additions to the Greek Book of Daniel
The Prayer of Azariah and the Song of the Three Jews
Susanna
Bel and the Dragon
1 Maccabees
2 Maccabees
(b) Books in the Greek and Slavonic Bibles; not in the Roman Catholic Canon
1 Esdras (=2 Esdras in Slavonic =3 Esdras in Appendix to Vulgate)
Prayer of Manasseh (in Appendix to Vulgate)
Psalm 151, following Psalm 150 in the Greek Bible
3 Maccabees
(c) In the Slavonic Bible and in the Latin Vulgate Appendix
2 Esdras (=3 Esdras in Slavonic =4 Esdras in Vulgate Appendix) (Note: In the Latin Vulgate, Ezra-Nehemiah 1 and 2 Esdras.)
(d) In an Appendix to the Greek Bible
4 Maccabees

The New Testament


Matthew--last third of first century
Mark--first gospel written; prior to fall of Jerusalem in 70 CE
Luke --last third of first century
John --90-100 CE
Acts of the Apostles--second part of Luke's gospel
Romans --55 or 56 CE
1 Corinthians--Paul founded the church and remained there 50-51 CE
2 Corinthians
Galatians--55 or 56 CE
Ephesians --while Paul was a prisoner, same time as Colossians, early 60's
Philippians--Paul's imprisonment at Rome 61-63 CE
Colossians --early 60's
1 Thessalonians --written in Corinth, early 50's
2 Thessalonians --written in Corinth, early 50's
1 Timothy--language, akin to second century Christianity
2 Timothy--language, akin to second century Christianity
Titus--language, akin to second century Christianity
Philemon --while Paul was under house arrest at Rome, 61-63 CE
Hebrews --written prior to fall of Jerusalem
James --written by hellenistic Christian at end of first century
1 Peter --after Neronian persecution in CE 64
2 Peter --after Neronian persecution in CE 64
1 John --end of first century
2 John--end of first century
3 John --end of first century
Jude --80 C.E
Revelation --end of reign of Emperor Domitian 81-96 CE

 

The Number and Sequence of the Books of the Bible(Oxford Companion) 
 

THE OLD TESTAMENT
According to Jewish usage the twenty-four books of the Hebrew Scriptures fall into three divisions: the Law, the Prophets, and the Writings. The Prophets are divided into the Former Prophets and the Latter Prophets (the terms "former" and "latter" refer to their position in the list, and have no reference to date of composition). The books of Samuel, Kings, Chronicles, Ezra-Nehemiah were not divided by the Jews until the close of the Middle Ages. The twelve Minor Prophets are treated as one book. The two subdivisions of the Prophets therefore contain four books each. In most editions of the Hebrew Bible the sequence of the books is as follows:


The Law (five books):
Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, Deuteronomy.
The Prophets (eight books):
Former Prophets:
Joshua, Judges, Samuel (1 and 2), Kings (1 and 2).
Latter Prophets:
Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel, the Twelve (=Hosea, Joel, Amos, Obadiah, Jonah, Micah, Nahum, Habakkuk, Zephaniah, Haggai, Zechariah, Malachi).
The Writings (eleven books):
Psalms, Proverbs, Job, Song of Solomon, Ruth, Lamentations, Ecclesiastes, Esther, Daniel, Ezra-Nehemiah, Chronicles (1 and 2).

In Protestant editions of the Bible the Old Testament follows the Hebrew text as regards content, but the books in the second and third divisions are rearranged in sequence and several are divided, making a total of thirty-nine.

In Roman Catholic editions the Old Testament contains the rearranged thirty-nine books of the Hebrew Scriptures plus seven others that are current in the official Latin Vulgate Bible and that Protestants include among the Apocrypha. The order of these forty-six books in Vulgate manuscripts varies greatly; in fact, the manuscripts that have been examined disclose more than two hundred different ways of arranging the books. In current editions of Roman Catholic Bibles (including the Douay Version, the Jerusalem Bible, and the New American Bible), Tobit and Judith stand after Nehemiah; 1 and 2 Maccabees, after Esther (except in the Douay Version, in which these books conclude the Old Testament); Wisdom and Ecclesiasticus, after the Song of Solomon; and Baruch, with the Letter of Jeremiah as ch. 6, after Lamentations. Furthermore, the books of Esther and Daniel are expanded by several additional chapters and parts of chapters, which Protestants regard as apocryphal. They comprise six Additions to the book of Esther and the following three supplements to the book of Daniel: the Prayer of Azariah and the Song of the Three Jews, Susanna, and Bel and the Dragon.

In the original Douay Version of 1609-1610 an appendix after the close of the Old Testament contains three other books, and 4 Esdras (called 1 and 2 Esdras by Protestants) and the Prayer of Manasseh. These are regarded as apocryphal by Roman Catholics as well as by Protestants. It is curious that in the Geneva Bible of 1560, widely used by the Puritans, the Prayer of Manasseh is included in the Old Testament between 2 Chronicles and Ezra, though in the table of contents it is designated as apocryphal.

The Greek Orthodox Church, which uses the Greek Septuagint Version as its official text, has generally been accustomed to follow the longer canon of the Old Testament, including in this case also the 151st Psalm and 3 Maccabees. The Seventh Ecumenical Council held at Nicaea in 787 and the Council convened by Basil in Constantinople in 869 quote certain Apocrypha as authoritative. On the other hand, writers who raised the issue concerning the limits of the canon, such as John of Damascus and Nicephorus, express views that coincide with those of Athanasius, who adhered to the Hebrew canon. In the Schism of 1054 the Apocrypha were not an issue, though they became such during the Protestant Reformation. At that time a short-lived attempt was made by Cyril Lucar, Patriarch of Constantinople, to promote the adoption of the Hebrew canon in the Greek Church. Subsequently, however, the Synod of Jerusalem (1672) condemned Cyril and expressly designated the books of Tobit, Judith, Ecclesiasticus (Sirach), and Wisdom as canonical.

By way of summary, the Roman Catholic Church and the Greek Orthodox Church agree in regarding as authoritative certain books that they call deuterocanonical and that Protestants call apocryphal. In addition the following books are considered apocryphal by Protestants and Roman Catholics, but are in the Greek canon when indicated.
1 Esdras (=Esdras A in the Greek canon; 3 Esdras in Appendix to Latin Vulgate).
2 Esdras (=4 Esdras in Appendix to Latin Vulgate).

Prayer of Manasseh (in the Greek canon; in Appendix to Latin Vulgate).
Psalm 151 and 3 Maccabees (in the Greek canon; 4 Maccabees in Appendix Greek canon).


In order to set forth clearly the several differences in usage among the Churches, the New Revised Standard Version presents the text of the Apocryphal/ Deuterocanonical Books in four successive groupings, as follows: (a) Books and Additions to Esther and Daniel that are in Roman Catholic, Greek, and Slavonic Bibles; (b) Books in the Greek and Slavonic Bibles, not in the Roman Catholic canon; (c) In the Slavonic Bible and the Latin Vulgate Appendix; (d) In an Appendix to the Greek Bible.

One can readily understand, therefore, why the reader does not find, for example; 3 and 4 Maccabees directly following 1 and 2 Maccabees.

THE NEW TESTAMENT
The number and the sequence of the twenty-seven books of the New Testament are the same in Protestant, Roman Catholic, and Eastern Orthodox Bibles.

A comparison of the extant manuscripts of the New Testament discloses that the early Church was accustomed to arrange them in four groups: (1) the Gospels, (2) the Acts and the General, or Catholic, Letters (that is, the seven letters which bear the names of James, Peter, John, and Jude), (3) the Pauline Letters, (4) the Apocalypse (as in the fifth-century codex Alexandrinus and many other manuscripts). Sometimes the Pauline Letters precede the Acts and General Letters, thus placing first the books which had earliest obtained canonical authority (as in the fourth-century codex Sinaiticus and the sixth-century codex Fuldensis).

Within each of the four groups there was a great variety of order. In the early Western Church the Gospel sequence most commonly followed was that of Matthew, John, Luke, Mark—namely, the Gospels attributed to apostles preceding those attributed to disciples of the apostles. The Letter to the Hebrews had no fixed place; sometimes it stood at the end of the Pauline Letters, sometimes between Paul’s Letters to churches and those to individuals (that is, between 2 Thessalonians and 1 Timothy), and occasionally after Romans (as in the third-century Chester Beatty Papyrus) or after Galatians (as in an ancestor of the fourth-century codex Vaticanus, as is disclosed by the section numbers in Vaticanus). In the West the Letters of Peter were frequently placed first among the General Letters.


The current order of the Pauline and the General Letters seems to have been drawn up roughly in accord with length, the longest one in each group (Paul to churches, Paul to individuals, and General Letters) standing first and the shortest one, last.

 

Lineages:

Lineages: From Oxford Notes

...Previous

 

New Testament

 

The New Testament contains two genealogies of Jesus: one in Matthew 1.1–16, which traces his descent from Abraham, and one in Luke 3.23–38, which reverses the order. While Matthew’s genealogy is limited to the Abrahamic line, Luke’s goes back to Adam. Perhaps as a mnemonic device, Matthew or his source divided the generations from Abraham to Jesus into three groups of fourteen (Matthew 1.17): fourteen generations from Abraham to David, fourteen from David to the Babylonian exile, and fourteen from the Babylonian exile to Jesus. In order to maintain the symmetry, the names of the kings Ahaziah, Joash, and Amaziah were dropped from the second list of fourteen between Joram (Jehoram) and Uzziah. Other omissions may have occurred in Matthew’s third list of fourteen, because Luke, who presents a different lineage between Zerubbabel and Joseph, records nineteen names for the same period.

Matthew’s genealogy seems to be intentionally formed around a predetermined number. Most likely he meant to show that Jesus is a royal descendant of Abraham and David, in fact a new David: the sum of the numerical value of the Hebrew consonants in the name “David” (d + w + d = 4 + 6+ 4) is fourteen, and Jesus is frequently called “son of David” throughout the gospel of Matthew.

Four women appear in Matthew’s list, though they are not found in Luke’s. This is notable because in biblical times lineage was traced through males. Even more surprising is that three of these women were non-Israelites: Rahab the Canaanite, Ruth the Moabite, and (presumably) Bathsheba, the wife of Uriah the Hittite. Their mention anticipates the inclusion of gentiles among Jesus’ disciples (Matthew 28.19).

The genealogy in Luke 3.23–38 has variations in different textual traditions. According to most Greek manuscripts (followed by the United Bible Societies’ Greek New Testament), there are 11 × 7 generations from Adam to Jesus (that is, from Adam to Abraham, 3 × 7 generations; from Isaac to David, 2 × 7 generations; from Nathan to Salathiel (preexilic), 3 × 7 generations; from Zerubbabel (postexilic) to Jesus, 3 × 7 generations). Other Greek manuscripts, the Latin Vulgate, and the Syriac Peshitta record 76 generations, and some Latin manuscripts list 72 generations. Most likely Luke traces Jesus’ genealogy back through Abraham to Adam to show that Jesus is not only the fulfillment of the history of Israel, but also that he is the savior of the world.

Many attempts have been made to reconcile the two genealogies, which after David agree in only two names (Shealtiel [Salathiel] and Zerubbabel). Because none of these attempts have been generally accepted, it is likely that these inconsistent genealogies serve separate literary functions and are not to be interpreted like modern registers of pedigree. Matthew’s genealogy is meant to show Jesus’ Davidic, royal descent, and Luke’s to underscore the universal role of Jesus as Son of God.

The word genealogy occurs twice in a disparaging sense: in 1 Timothy 1.4 (“endless genealogies that promote speculations”), and in Titus 3.9 (“avoid … genealogies … for they are unprofitable”). Because the larger contexts refer to myths, the allusions may be to the various emanations (“aeons”) between God and humankind in gnostic belief. Or, since Titus 1.14 relates to Jewish myths and 1 Timothy 1.7 calls into question the claims of those who desire to be teachers of the Law, the genealogies referred to may be based on biblical sources but elaborated in the same way as the Book of Jubilees and more generally aggadah.

            Bruce M. Metzger

Visual Structure (J. Sidlowe Baxter)

The following provides an easy memory device for learning an ordering of the books of the Bible that will stay in the student's mind; all a student has to do initially is remember 5, 12; 5; 5, 12 or 17; 5; 17 to group the books in the Old Testament. The New Testament is equally easy: 5, 9; 4, 9.
 

Old Testament
Visual Structure: 5, 12 (9, 3); 5; 5, 12 (9, 3) or 17 (5, 12 [9,3]); 5; 17 (5, 12 [9, 3])

5-Pentateuch Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, Deuteronomy

12History Joshua, Judges, Ruth, I, II Samuel, I, II Kings, I, II Chronicles (9 pre-exile) Ezra, Nehemiah, Esther (3 post-exile)

5--Writings Job, Psalms, Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, Song of Solomon

5-Major Prophets Isaiah, Jeremiah, Lamentations, Ezekiel, Daniel

12- Minor Prophets (9  pre-exilic) Joel, Amos, Obadiah, Jonah, Micah, Nahum, Habakkuk, Zephaniah (3 post-exilic) Haggai, Zechariah, Malachi

New Testament
Visual Structure: 5, 9, 4, 9
Types Structure
5 -Foundation (Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, Acts)
9 -Christian letters (Romans, I, II Corinthians, Galatians, Ephesians, Philippians, Colossians, I, II Thessalonians)
4 Pastoral: I, II Timothy, Titus, Philemon
9 Hebrew: Hebrews, James, I, II Peter, I, II, III John, Jude, Revelation

Links: 6/16/03
The Bible Format

Overview of Bible

Summary of Bible

Introduction to Bible

Thematic Approach to Order

The Bible Library  John Drane’s Introducing the Old Testament, HarpersSanFrancisco, 1987.

Law Books

Pentateuch: five books traditionally associated with Moses, contains accounts of humanity’s beginnings.  (Genesis 1-11), accounts of Israel’s forefathers (the rest of Genesis), and accounts of Israel’s escape from Egypt and journey to the promised land (parts of Exodus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy).  But above all, it contains ‘laws’: regulations for religious and social life, and great moral laws built on the Ten Commandments.

History Books

These books tell the story of the Israelites from their first entry into Canaan until their return there after exile in Babylon. Joshua and Judges are about the conquest and settlement of the land.  The books of Samuel are mainly about Kings Saul and David, and Kings concerns first Solomon and then the kings of the divided kingdoms until the monarchy ended with the exile.  Chronicles covers similar ground from  a different viewpoint, and is linked to Ezra and Nehemiah and the resto of the stories of the returned exiles.

Poetry and Wisdom Books

The book of Psalms  is the hymnbook of the Old Testament, containing a wide variety of poems on both personal and national themes.  The three wisdom books are very different from each other: Job is a dramatic poem on the problem of suffering, Ecclesiastes is a set of reflections on the apparent meaninglessness of existence, and Proverbs is a collection of wise sayings about everyday living.  The Song of Solomon is a love poem.

Book of Prophecies

There were prophets right through Old Testament times, from Moses on.  The prophecies of the great prophets from the last three hundred years of Old Testament history were collected in writing. The major prophets—Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel—are long books each developing a characteristic understanding of God and his ways.  Daniel is part story, part apocrypha.  The twelve minor prophets reveal the word of God as given in a variety of ways at different periods of history.

The Bible Narrative People of the Covenant, Oxford University Press,1996

Narratives of Creation and Fall Genesis 1-11 These narratives set the background for understanding the rest of the Hebrew story.  These chapters make profound statements about the creation of the world and the beginnings of humankind and history: these are questions concerning primary significance and are not answered easily by science.  The fundamental human predicament—that of separation from God through choice—is addressed by God’s work through Israel’s history.  The questions answered in these chapters are those of who we are, how we’re related to the world and each other, and what the nature of ultimate reality is. Almost no historically concrete data appears: these are events and people representative of humankind. Genesis makes clear from the beginning that for the Hebrews, human history begins with the intervention of God as creator: God very simply is stated to be.  From that evolves human history and its rebellion against the Creator.  Responsible relationship means recognition of God and human beings as significance in carrying Godly image.  Human beings existentially wrestle with reality and their own egotistical denial of the sovereignty of the Creator.

The fact that Genesis poses these questions in its first chapters should suggest to the student that here is enough reason for the reading of this book and the others that make up this anthology.

The scripture is clear: God (stated simply as fact) created an orderly world. Whatever else science and religion may disagree on, both agree that light belonged to the early creation. It might be noted that light is present even before the creation of the sun.Unlike surrounding mythologies, Genesis makes clear that the sun and moon are not divinities; they are markers of time—the difference between day and night. The authority for creation is also clear: God created by word.

Whatever is recorded in primeval history, the account is taken up from a distance by a people who are looking back from what is to what has been: the Edenic experience ends quickly—by chapter three.  From this point--from expulsion from the ideal into the real, from unity into disunity, alienation, and brokenness—the finite experience is characterized by aspiration and crushing limitation.  History and the space-time box becomes the saga of human suffering in the god-like act of bridging the pressing dichotomies of the creature separated from it Creator. Genesis three tells the story sadly: the Lord God walks in the garden in the cool of the day, but man and wife hide themselves from Divine presence.  They are naked, vulnerable, and eager to explain away the responsibility for their acts.  The future is clear: for humans, relentless activity (work), desire, pain, and mortality replace the rest and blessing of God’s sabbath rest.  The theme will be taken up over and over in the books to come: Canaan will be the land of promise which can be taken only by the futile actions of human conquest; the book of Hebrews takes up the story: the Israelites had failed to enter into God’s rest—“there remains a sabbath rest for the people of Hod; for whoever enters God’s rest also ceases from his labors as God did from his (4.8). Only in Revelation, when the old has passed away,  when the dwelling place of God is with us, will our tears be wiped away, our pain assuaged, and death and mourning be ended (21.3,4).  Genesis through Revelation is then the story of the journey away from and back to the ideal—away from and back to unity.  The narrative dips back into the primeval and prehistorical and soars into futuristic vision.  From alienation, pain, suffering, and despair, the voice of God’s spokespeople—the prophets among us—return us to what we were and hold out for what we can become.

 

“Israel’s worship celebrated Yahweh, who was lord and controller of history… the creator and sustainer of creation” (People of the Covenant, 96).  The faith of the Hebrew was a faith in the Creator of creation and the Controller of history.

The Biblical narratives are those of the creation and fall, the patriarchal and matriarchal forebears, the exodus and giving of the law and wanderings in the wilderness; the story is that of Israel in Canaan, its worship in Jerusalem, the periods before, after, and during exile; sprinkled in are the narratives of worship, wisdom, instruction,and poetry.

Bible Transmission

The collection of thirty-nine books in the Old and New Testament is an anthology of heterogeneous writings. These are books of history, instruction, and prophecy. The Old Testament scripturally is called simply  Holy Scripture, Scripture, or Law.  The common designation is that of “the Law and the Prophets” or “Moses and the Prophets.”   In Luke (24.44), it is called “Law, prophets, and psalms.” In 130 CE, Jesus ben Sirach referred to it as “Law, prophets, and other books of our ancestors.”

The Old Testament  (Curt Kuhl, The Old Testament,  John Knox Press, 1961) is written in West Semitic Hebrew, the language common to Canaan and Judah. In a very few places, we find Aramaic.  The alphabetical script is written from right to left in the older books. The Hebrew quadrat script or Assyrian script appeared after the exile and was introduced by Ezra for the Torah.  The oldest documents were carved in stone (Exodus 31.18, 34.1), engraved on tablets (Isaiah 30.8, Habakkuk 11.2) of clay or lead, or written on book rolls with a pen (Psalms 45.1 and Jeremiah 36/18).  Ezekiel speaks of carrying an ink horn at the belt (9.2).The picture of King Jehoiakim slashing off columns of Scripture dictated by Jeremiah (36.21) is an unforgettable one suggesting Egyptian papyrus as the material written upon—later to be replaced by leather or parchment. The translation of the Bible had to be then a laborious one as well as costly, requiring painstaking copying and subject to human fallibility. The miracle of miracles is that we have the old transcripts we have and that we have the intricate unity of the thirty-nine books recognized as belonging to the canon.

The way in which the books of the Bible are counted leads to the premature conclusion that books are being omitted; differences in count, however, can be explained by an old Jewish tradition which counted the twelve minor prophets, the two books of Samuel, Kings, and Chronicles as one book; this is also true of Ezra and Nehemiah.  Josephus further reduced the number by including Ruth with Judges and Lamentations with Jeremiah.

The Oxford Companion to the Bible summarizes these structural differences at some length:

An anonymous tannaitic tradition (Bab. Bat. 14b), no later than ca. 200 ce, lists the order of the books of the Prophets and the Writings. This presents a problem because the codex form was not adopted by Jews before the fifth century ce and because the general and favored scribal practice—with one exception—was to restrict each scroll to a single biblical book. What then is the meaning of term “order” in the rabbinic text? The most likely explanation is that it refers to the manner of storage and the system of classification and cataloguing in vogue in the libraries and schools of Palestine. The library procedures of the Hellenistic world would have required each of the three collections of canonical works to be placed in a separate armarium, with the scrolls arranged in their appropriately assigned order.

The sequence of the Former Prophets following the Pentateuch is: Joshua, Judges, Samuel, Kings. This arrangement never varies and presents one long continuous history of Israel from the beginning of the conquest to the fall of the Judean kingdom, the Babylonian exile, and the release of King Jehoiachin from prison in 561 bce. (See Deuteronomic History.)

The variations in the order of the books occur in the Latter Prophets and particularly in the Writings. A majority of manuscripts and most printed Bibles feature Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel, which is the proper historical order. The above-cited source, however, followed by some manuscripts, lists Isaiah in third place in juxtaposition with its contemporary Hosea. Another tradition has Jeremiah after Kings and before Isaiah and Ezekiel. This is because that prophet was active during the last years of the monarchy, and Jeremiah 39 and Jeremiah 52 largely duplicate 2 Kings 25.

The small prophetic books, generally known as the “Minor Prophets,” were habitually transcribed onto a single scroll and were collectively designated “The Twelve” (so already in Sirach 49.10, ca. 180 bce). Their internal arrangement is: Hosea, Joel, Amos, Obadiah, Jonah, Micah, Nahum, Habakkuk, Zephaniah, Haggai, Zechariah, Malachi. This is also the order of a scroll of the second century ce from Wadi Murabba>at (See Dead Sea Scrolls) containing the Hebrew Minor Prophets, and it apparently reflected traditional views about their historical sequence. The same order, but with Micah following Amos and succeeded by Joel, is given in 2 Esdras 1.39–40. This groups together three prophets of the eighth century bce.

The order of the Writings in Hebrew printed Bibles is: Psalms, Proverbs, Job, Song of Solomon, Ruth, Lamentations, Ecclesiastes, Esther, Daniel, Ezra, Nehemiah, Chronicles. Passages like 2 Maccabees 2.13–14 and Luke 24.44 seem to attest to the great antiquity of the initial place of Psalms. The aforementioned tannaitic source has Ruth before Psalms due to the concluding genealogy of David, the reputed author of the Psalter. The Aleppo Codex (end of ninth century ce and the Leningrad Codex of 1008 ce both open the Writings with Chronicles, probably because that work duplicates the Pentateuchal genealogies and much of the Former Prophets.

The tannaitic practice, also found in manuscripts and ultimately standardized in the printed editions, was to conclude the Hebrew scriptures with Chronicles following Ezra-Nehemiah. This must have been a very early tradition, for it is reflected in Matthew 23.35 and Luke 11.51. The inversion of the chronological order must have arisen out of a desire to close the canon on a note of consolation, and to make the statement that the fulfillment of biblical prophecy involves the return of the Jewish people to its ancestral land. Apart from this messianic exegesis, it also serves to encase the Hebrew scriptures within a framework of historical narrative, for Chronicles begins with Adam and its last sentence contains the same two key Hebrew verbs of redemption with which Genesis concludes (pqd, >lh, Genesis 50.24–25; 2 Chronicles 36.23).

Christian editions reverse the order of Prophets-Writings, so that the closing words of Malachi (Malachi 4.5–6 [3.23–24 in Hebrew]) concerning Elijah become transitional to the New Testament, and connect with the role of John the Baptist (see Matthew 11.13–14; Mark 1.2; Mark 9.11–13; Luke 1.16–17).

Least stable in respect of order are the small books in the corpus of the Writings. The tannaitic source follows Proverbs with Ecclesiastes and the Song of Solomon because all three are attributed to King Solomon. Most medieval manuscripts preserve this association in one way or another. Lamentations, Daniel, and Esther are grouped together since they all belong to the period of the exile. In medieval times, the Song of Solomon, Ruth, Lamentations, Ecclesiastes, and Esther were all clustered together in that order, based upon their use as lectionaries in the cycle of the Jewish religious calendar, commencing with Passover. This system became the rule in the printed editions. Greek Bibles differ considerably from the Hebrew scriptures in that the books are arranged according to genres of literature. Ignoring the additional Apocrypha that are interspersed among the canonical works, the following classification emerges. First comes a narrative-historical collection that comprises the Pentateuch and Former Prophets, with Ruth attached to Judges, and Chronicles following Kings. Second is a prophetic collection consisting of: Isaiah; Jeremiah, to which is adjoined Lamentations for thematic reasons and traditions of authorship; Ezekiel; Daniel, because he is regarded as a prophet, a contemporary of Ezekiel, and is identified with the personality of that name mentioned in Ezekiel 14.14; Ezekiel 14.20; Ezekiel 28.3; and the Twelve in a slightly different internal order. The two complete Greek codices, the fourth-century ce Vaticanus and the fifth-century ce Alexandrinus, share these characteristics. However, the latter has Esther and Ezra-Nehemiah immediately after the prophetical collection, while the former places Ezra-Nehemiah after Chronicles. The third part is a poetic-didactic collection. Codex Vaticanus has Psalms, Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, Song of Solomon, Job, and Esther. The order of Codex Alexandrinus is Psalms, Job, Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, and Song of Solomon. Also the sequence of the second and third collections interchanges in the two codices.

Canon Selection Criteria

The Old and New Testament lay the basis for canonicity differently; in the New Testament, the emphasis is upon apostolic authority.  Other factors are used for the Old Testament: quality of inherent divine inspiration and authority recognizable to leaders of the Hebrew religious community through illumination by the Spirit of God (Moses, for example); role and authorship; and internal consistency of teaching and overall unity of theme and message; and use of books by the religious community.

Moses and the Seventy Prophets

(Numbers 11.18-30)

God says to Moses, when he asked why the burden of a people craving meat has been laid upon him, that he is to find seventy elders: “I will come down and talk to you there [Moses’ tent]; and I will take some of the spirit which is upon you and put it upon them; and they shall bear the burden the people with you” (11.17). A later verse (25) reveals that the Lord came down in a cloud and rested upon the seventy and they prophesied.

Looking at the human writers of the Bible, one discovers quickly that roles are important: we find lawgivers, judges, prophets, priests, and kings.

The “Word of the Lord” is largely a reporting of the covenant experience.  In the covenant, these books achieve unity of theme and message.

The religious community studied, copied, and obeyed the books they considered sacred.  Their use of particular documents no doubt affected canon selection and consistently used books came to be known as belonging to the canon.

Disputed Books

Some books were “spoken against” because their interpretation was an issue: Esther (because it nowhere includes the name of God), Proverbs (more earthly than divine wisdom), Ecclesiastes (pessimistic and hedonistic overtones), and Song of Solomon (erotic nature of love poetry); and Ezekiel (due to bizarre antics and visions and teachings on sacrifice).

Apocrypha

This collection of books comes from the intertestamental period. Depending on numeration, the apocryphas books are fourteen or fifteen. These books were composed between 200 BCE and 100 CE. The books are written in Hebrew, Greek, and Aramaic; they are preserved in Greek, Latin, Ethiopic, Copic, Arabic, Syriac, and Armenian languages.  They include six genres: didactic (teachings), religious, romantic, historical, prophetic epistolary and apocalyptic, and legendary literature. 

Martin Luther’s assessment of the Apocrypha is valid for understanding the Protestant rejection of the Apocryphal books as canonical: they are not equal to the Holy Scriptures but are profitable to read and valuable for personal edification. Pointedly, however, with the rejection of these books, a gap of four hundred silent years seems to exist between the Old Testament and the New.  To learn about this history, one needs to read these books as well as the early historians. The Oxford Companion  describes the Apocrypha in the following way:

The name, which means “things hidden away,” is inappropriate, since none of these books (with the possible exception of 2 Esdras) was ever regarded as hidden or secret. For the most part, they are simply those books found only in manuscripts of the Septuagint (LXX), the ancient Greek translation of the Hebrew scriptures, and therefore possibly regarded as “canonical” by Greek-speaking Alexandrian Jews, though ultimately rejected by the Jewish community of Palestine and rabbinic authorities of later times (2 Esdras and the Prayer of Manasseh are not covered by this definition). Their preservation is largely due to the Christian community, which, for most of the first four centuries ce, accepted the Greek Old Testament as normative for its life and thought. In modern times the term “apocrypha” has been extended more loosely to other books from the later Hellenistic and early Roman periods but which, so far as we know, never attained even quasi-canonical status (these books are more commonly designated as pseudepigrapha), and has also been extended by analogy to a large group of early Christian writings excluded from the New Testament canon in its final form.

Whatever else is concluded, students should realize that these fourteen books were recognized and widely circulated and read in both early Judaism and Christianity. Judaism began using portions of the Hebrew Bible as early as the period of the Babylonian exile (587 BCE); Christianity shared the Hebrew Bible with Judaism and began producing its own scripture, the letters of Paul being used by some Christians by the end of the first century.

The movement is clear: from works of literature, these books were elevated to scripture.  What may have happened in the establishing of a canon is that Jews moved to preserve, examine, and reconconsider what God’s will was His people. These characteristics are important for establishing any canon of literature, scriptural or otherwise: an ancient ancestry is preserved; what the past has been, what the present is, and what the future can be becomes clearer by self-examination; and how God has worked decisively in history and the purpose of humankind becomes a significant discovery of careful reconsideration. Because these people, indeed, are our ancestors, then we should want to study our inheritance.

Link:

Summaries of Apocryphal Books

 crain@missouriwestern.edu

Copyright 1997MWSC/Jeanie C. Crain All rights reserved.